Why do people talk about other people’s weight?
One of the girls I discussed this with began recovery by living in an intensive treatment center. Essentially, she had to because she couldn’t get better on her own. When she returned, a man she knew from work greeted her. He knew where she’d been and why she’d gone there and how serious it was. Nonetheless, the first words out of his mouth were, “Well, looks like you’ve put on some weight!” Entirely well-meant, of course, but you can see why that would bother her (or most girls, ED or no).
A nutritionist at Wheaton told me almost the same thing, but a little better – “you put on weight; you look good.” But at the time, it felt like she was trying to soften the truth (weight gain, which I didn’t like) with a compliment. A relative of mine told me, “I can tell you’ve put on weight.” Somewhat hurt, I tried to shrug it off, but she insisted, repeating, “You have, you’ve definitely put on weight.” In all honesty, it’s salt in the wound. I’m already struggling with my body image – do you have to remind me that I’m noticeable heavier? It’s sad because these people were obviously trying to compliment me, but instead they were triggering one of my biggest fears.
Aside from direct statements, any talk of weight can affect me (and, I’m sure, others). “So-and-so has definitely put on weight.” “So-and-so is skinny! She was always heavy, but she looks so good now.” Friends and family tell me my weight isn’t important, in attempt to help me fight anorexia. Then they can easily turn around and talk about other people’s weight, complimenting the slender and pointing out the overweight. To anyone, this could send a clear message that thinness reigns supreme. To someone with anorexia, it’s doubly painful.
It’s natural to notice others’ weight and maybe it’s natural to want to comment. It only bothers me because weight is such a touchy issue for many people, myself included. Even if you don’t have an ED, couldn’t you be affected by the attention other healthy people give to weight? Maybe I’m being unrealistic, but I wish people would think twice before praising/condemning any given weight.